Best Pizza In Rutherford Nj (2024)

FAQs

What is the oldest pizza place New Jersey? ›

Papa's Tomato Pies is the oldest family owned and continually run pizzeria in the U.S.A. It was established in 1912. First located on Butler Street in Trenton in 1912 and then moved to 802 Chambers Street in 1945 donating the original location to become the Neopolitan Hall .

Food writer Pete Genovese shares his top 5 pizzerias in the state.

An organization that ranks the best pies across the globe, 50 top Pizza, announced its 2023 list last night, handing out the top spot to I Masanielli in Caserta and 10 Diego Vitagliano Pizzeria in Naples.

The classic New Jersey pizza is known for its thin crust, crispy edges, and generous toppings. And let's not forget the iconic tomato sauce that is bursting with flavor. But what truly sets our pizza apart from the rest is the water.

New Jersey likes to bill itself as the pizza capital of America. Then, again, so does New York, Chicago and New Haven. In the latter case, Connecticut Governor Ned Lamont made that official (at least as far as his state's pizza lovers are concerned) in a proclamation earlier this month.

New Jersey native Anthony Mangieri's Una Pizza Napoletana, previously named the No. 1 pizzeria in America, was named No. 2 in the world. Razza has become one of the most influential pizzerias in the country over the last 10-plus years it has been serving pizza in Jersey City.

Specialties specific to New Jersey diners include the previously mentioned pork roll, egg, and cheese sandwich, as well as disco fries, a food similar to the Quebec dish of poutine. They consist of french fries, usually slightly overcooked, and covered with brown gravy and melted mozzarella cheese.

It's all in the tomatoes.

New Jersey is known for our tomatoes almost as much as our pizza. Our location affords us very good climate conditions, and our soil is high in loam (sand, silt, clay). Combined, this gives us those delicious tomatoes we love to eat. These tomatoes help to make the incredible sauce we love.

Pequod's Pizzeria in Chicago, known for its deep-dish pies, earned the top spot.

Compiled based on Yelp Elites' shared favorites ("our most passionate and trusted reviewers and influencers," the company explains in a statement), the survey, which you can browse through in full right here, crowns Pequod's Pizzeria in Chicago as the very best of its kind in America.

What is the most loved pizza? ›

1. Pepperoni. This may not come as a surprise, but pepperoni is by far the most popular pizza topping in the United States.

Quick service pizza chains in the U.S. with the highest sales 2022. With sales worth approximately 8.57 billion U.S. dollars, Domino's Pizza was the leading quick service pizza chain in the United States in 2022. Pizza Hut and Little Caesars ranked second and third, respectively.

In 1830, Antica Pizzeria Port'Alba was opened in Naples. Most historians consider this to be the world's first pizzeria. It became a meeting place for artists, students or others with little money so, in most cases, the pizza was simple.

Welcome to America's First Pizzeria^®, Est. 1905 | NYC

Lombardi is credited with developing New York Style pizza and making Lombardi's the first pizzeria in the United States.

Shakey's Pizza is a pizza restaurant chain based in the United States and The Philippines. Founded in 1954, it was the first franchise pizza chain in the United States.