What Is a Fund of Funds (FOF)?
A fund of funds (FOF)—also known as a multi-manager investment—is a pooled investment fund that invests in other types of funds. In other words, its portfolio contains different underlying portfolios of other funds. These holdings replace any investing directly in bonds, stocks, and other types of securities.
FOFs usually invest in other mutual funds or hedge funds. They are typically classified as "fettered," or only able to invest in funds managed by the FOF's managing company, or "unfettered," or able to invest in funds across the market.
Key Takeaways
- A fund of funds (FOF) is a pooled fund that invests in other funds.
- FOFs usually invests in other hedge funds or mutual funds.
- The fund of funds strategy aims to achieve broad diversification and minimal risk.
- Funds of funds tend to have higher expense ratios than regular mutual funds.
How a Fund of Funds (FOF) Works
The fund of funds (FOF) strategy aims to achieve broad diversification and appropriate asset allocation with investments in a variety of fund categories that are all wrapped into one portfolio.
There are different kinds of FOFs, with each type acting on a different investment scheme. A FOF may be structured as a mutual fund, a hedge fund, a private equity fund, or an investment trust. The FOF may be fettered, meaning it only invests in portfolios managed by one investment company. Alternatively, the FOF can be unfettered, letting it invests in external funds controlled by other managers from other companies.
Fund of Funds Advantages
Typically, FOFs attract small investors who want to get better exposure with fewer risks compared to directly investing in securities—or even in individual funds. Investing in a FOF gives the investor professional wealth management services and expertise.
Investing in a FOF also allows investors with limited capital to tap into diversified portfolios with different underlying assets. Many of these would be out-of-reach for the average retail investor. For example, hedge funds typically require six-figure minimum investments or require investors to have a minimum net worth—or both.
Most FOFs require a formal due-diligence procedure for their fund managers—both their own and those managing the underlying funds. Applying managers' backgrounds are checked, which ensures the portfolio handler's background and credentials in the securities industry.
Fund of Funds Disadvantages
Though FOFs provide diversification and less exposure to market volatility, these returns may be lessened by investment fees that are typically higher than traditional investment funds. Higher fees come from the compounding of fees on top of fees.
Like most mutual funds, a FOF carries an annual operating expense—known as the expense ratio—as well as management fees and operating costs. However, FOFs investors are essentially paying double—because the underlying funds in the FOF all have their annual costs and fees, too.
In the past, funds of funds' prospectuses didn't always include the fees of the underlying funds. As of January 2007, the SEC began requiring that these fees be disclosed in a line called Acquired Fund Fees and Expenses (AFFE).
A fund of funds might charge annual management fees of 0.5% to 1% to invest in funds that charge another 1% annual management fee. So, the FOF investor in sum is paying up to 2%. Small wonder that, after allocating the money invested to fees and other payable taxes, the returns of fund of funds investments may generally be lower compared to the profits that single-manager funds can provide—even if the funds perform very well.
Picking good fund managers and funds can be difficult, too—especially if the FOF is fettered. The FOF may end up owning the same stock or other security through several different funds, thus reducing the actual diversification.
Pros
Ultimate in diversification
Professional management expertise
Alleviation of risk and volatility
Exposure to assets usually beyond small investors
Cons
Additional layer of fees
Risk of overlap in holdings
Difficulty in finding qualified managers, funds
Real-World Example for Fund of Funds
Since they are so varied, funds of funds can be hard to track as a group and to compare. However, an index does exist. The Barclay Fund of Funds Index, sponsored by Barclay-Hedge, a provider of data on alternative investments, is a measure of the average return of all FOFs that report into the company database. Through Q1 2022, for instance, 156 funds of funds had yielded an average return of 0.33% year-to-date. The S&P 500 during the same period lost more than 7.5%.
Are Funds of Funds Common?
Dedicated funds of funds may be less common that standalone mutual funds or ETFs. However, the SEC estimates that approximately 40% of all registered funds hold an investment in at least one other fund.
How Much Assets Are Invested in Funds of Funds?
According to the SEC, Total net assets in mutual funds that invest primarily in other mutual funds reached over $2.54 trillion in 2019.
Are Funds of Funds Regulated by the SEC?
Yes, like all other pooled investment products, FOF are also overseen by the SEC. In particular, SEC Rule 12d1-4, updated in 2020, sets out procedures that provide a consistent framework for fund of funds arrangements. The SEC also requires FOFs to disclose their fees in a transparent manner.
